Subscribe to the Port Washington News Home Delivery

Attn Big Data: Hands Off Our Kids

Owens_weekly_010314Don’t mess with the moms. Okay, nor the dads. But especially the moms. Because they are not going to get tired or get shooed away. Just ask Deborah Abramson Brooks and Allison White.

“My daughter is a minor, and it is my job to protect her,” said Brooks, whose nine-year-old daughter is in the fourth grade in Port Washington public schools.

“In my gut, as a mother, I fear what is going to happen,”said White, who has two sons in Port Washington’s Schreiber High School and another who is a senior at Columbia University.

The scary threat they are talking about is inBloom, Inc., an Atlanta-based corporation funded by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, that is working with state governments to get just about every bit of data that can be gotten about our kids, storing it, crunching it, and making our kids’ educational careers — and basically their lives — so much spreadsheet fodder.

As it stands now, the New York State Education Department is planning to turn over the names and records of more than two million public school students to inBloom. These kids include yours. Brooks and White are fighting back.

“I’m not doing this just for my kids,” said White. “I’m doing this because I think it is wrong.”

The two moms have put together an on-line petition that opposes “the creation of this database and the collection, storage, and release (potentially to for-profit companies) of any and all confidential and private personally identifiable information without the express consent of parents or legal guardians.”

inBloom wants to amass more than 400 data points on each kid — name, address, grades, test scores, disciplinary and health records, disabilities, race, ethnicity, economic status and so on. The company says that its mission is to “inform and involve each student and teacher with data and tools designed to personalize learning.”

Benign? Well, that depends on how the data is used. It also raises the question of how much data is really needed to figure out what a kid knows, needs to know, and how that kid is progressing. With all of the information inBloom will have on each student, you can be told with the seeming authority of data, precisely how your kid should be educated. The state or local districts could enforce these inBloom-derived directions. inBloom will “know” whether particular schools and teachers are good or bad, whether playing in the school band or preparing for a standardized test leads to a better “student outcome,” or even whether you’re a good or bad parent. It’s all easy to find in the data.

The information inBloom gathers will be kept in “the cloud,” managed by Amazon. Assurances from inBloom and the State Education Department that this information is hack-proof are a lot less believable since information on 40 million Target customers was compromised. Plus, inBloom’s underlying operating system was built by a company owned by Rupert Murdoch. (“Hey, wasn’t his company implicated in Britain’s phone-hacking scandal?”)

But even more fundamental, Brooks and White say, is that inBloom is a violation of the right to privacy.

“We parents have to have control over what happens to our children’s information,” said White. “We are their protectors.”

While various organizations (such as and ad-hoc groups on Facebook are fighting New York’s embrace of inBloom, Brooks and White believe that “grass-roots” efforts are needed, not just to persuade local legislators to join the fight, but also to inform parents.

“I talk about it in the grocery store,” said Brooks. “This is something that almost everybody can agree on. And I want to get as many people as possible aware of it.”

At press-time, nearly 2,000 people from around the state had signed the petition. And their local law-makers are on their side.

“Parents have an absolute right to protect their children in all things — that includes preventing the State Education Department from sharing a child’s information with a third party without their knowledge and consent,” said Sen. Jack M. Martins’ (R-Mineola), who has a bill in the Senate that prevents student information from being shared with third parties unless there is parental consent. He plans on reintroducing it when the legislative session starts this month.

Assemblywoman Michelle Schimel (D-Great Neck) is on board, too. An early opponent of the state’s inBloom plans, she has been pushing legislation to put the power — for opting in and opting out — in the parents’ hands.

“It is extremely troubling,” she said of the Education Department’s rush to join inBloom. “It is almost like everyone is marching forward over a cliff. It is time for someone to say ‘Stop!’”
The petition is at

John Owens is editor in chief of Anton Community Newspapers. Email:


  1. “The early couture pieces are rare,” agrees vintage dealer Cameron Silver of Decades. “I don’t see a lot of couture Mondrian dresses floating around, sadly.” With stylish A-listers like Gwyneth Paltrow, Chloë Sevigny, Kristin Davis and Rachel Griffiths known for their love of early YSL, Silver predicts to see even more of it on the red carpet, in particular pieces from the less elite Rive Gauche line, despite the fact that the most recent treasure trove to come to light was almost three years ago following socialite clotheshorse Nan Kempner’s 2005 death.

  2. The Hermes Birkin bag is sported by big celebrities and personalities, be it in Europe or in Hollywood. Because of this, Hermes bags have gained maximum media exposure, fueling the publics craving for the famous bags. Being the star among all Hermes bags, the Birkin bag has appeared in numerous Hollywood movies and television features. Despite its outrageous price, the demand for the bags sill isn’t going down, it’s probably just adding to its appeal.

  3. YSL’s New Vintage Collection Combines Eco

  4. mulberry alexacheap mulberry bags mulberry bags outlet

  5. great seller, quick shipper

  6. birkin hermes replica bags black replica hermes kelly watch japan zhttppt

  7. ロレックス デイトナ偽物時計:

  8. i enjoy your china these are generally soo adorable. i have got the actual ebenholzfarben designs nevertheless can’t find a large amount of costumes to pick each of them. of course, if naturally i the place where any of them these companies particular seem like i’m just extending santa offer china:( advice!

  9. Flint veut être un inventeur, mais son père insiste pour dire qu’il aide à la pêche de la famille et s’attaquer magasin de sardine. Son père éventuellement besoin d’aide parce qu’il n’a pas d’yeux visibles, seulement un sourcil broussailleux de plus en plus directement sur ​​son visage comme une haie poilu.
    Chemise Polo
    [url=]Chemise Polo[/url]

  10. We have purchased this one brand name of bracelet a number of instances. Every single one is extremely cute, prepared well, does not tarnish to meaningful depending on which kind of one particular you purchase furthermore whom shoppers render it at.

  11. sThe top quality it very good, nevertheless, simply because that the models operated mini accept this one shape up.If you’re 5f 4inches well length demands modifying or even really wear truly high footwear. Besides that liked that gown

  12. Well mother’s day gifts. Nevertheless, that the bracelet took quite long at appear, therefore came after the vacation. The mom indicated your she liked all bracelet, even though I’ve never observed her put on information technology though. :-)

  13. Very good headphoneschoose, well cost and exactly what are revealed. Breathtaking gift package to poem additionally enclosed. Awesome towards mother’s evening!

  14. I paid for this particular searching for a ideal gifts of the mom. That headphone arrived within a stunning purple tied up box. This is the best looking present underneath the christmas tree!! The particular headphone always looked breathtaking, nevertheless my mother was big boned and the headphone was a little tight, then again its a good gifts! I adore information technology.

  15. I acquired that looking for a awesome present towards our mama. Your headphone arrived within a stunning purple tied up container. This was ideal searching gift less than all christmas time tree!! The headphone furthermore seemed breathtaking, but our mom was great boned as well as the headphone is actually some tight, although its a good gift! I adore they.

  16. Bought this as being a gifts to my mother furthermore she liked that. awesome excellence wonderful cost plus the mother liked it. Always delivered extremely quick. When you require a present fast while like this compared to here is the one you really need to go for!

  17. I acquired your looking for a great gift for the my mother. Their headphone came in a stunning purple tied container. This is the best looking gift less than your xmas tree!! Your headphone in addition seemed striking, although my personal mom was larger boned and the headphone is a little tight, although its outstanding gifts! I really like that.

  18. But not like fancy when real world whether mothers wrist is actually never 2small do not choose this reason that it stay tight .. the attractive but anything yur 5year existing make . Non that the much less it is one ok present and bring yet not letter wow gift…cant go wrong in case dont have a lot to spend on a present after that buy this

  19. Good mother’s evening present. Still, all bracelet got besides prolonged in order to appear, therefore appeared after the getaway. My personal mother conveyed that will she liked that the bracelet, though I’ve maybe not observed her use this though. :-)

  20. I got the as being a gifts of the sibling, satisfied mother. She adored information technology!! I was afraid they is going to be too little because of the earlier feedback and exactly how they seemed when I took a peak, however it match quite nicely. This appearances striking upon as well as in the actual beautiful bundle it’s available in.

  21. Supplement came previous compared to planned, very quickly! It offers a great surface furthermore most brilliant colors. Really pleased with this particular find so inside-high-priced !:)adore information technology!

  22. Great headphoneschoose, nicely priced and also exactly what is displayed. Beautiful gift box and/or poem always enclosed. Great for mother’s evening!

  23. I acquired this particular looking for a very good present towards my mom. Some sort of headphone emerged in a breathtaking purple tied container. This is ideal lookin gifts under the particular xmas tree!! The particular headphone in addition seemed breathtaking, nevertheless the mom is actually great boned and the headphone is actually somewhat tight, although the outstanding gift! I love it.

  24. My wife shops at all the stores you mentioned above and in the last year or so has become enamored with Boden for online shopping. They are UK based but are now selling to the US and being from the UK, the styles and sizing is slightly different and the stuff my wife buys ends up looking pretty unique in a good way.

  25. Great mother’s day gift. Although, on bracelet got also long to arrive, therefore arrived following the getaway. My mother expressed your she liked some sort of bracelet, yet I have never observed this girl put on this however. :-)

  26. Photo: Paul MartinkaOne bright spot is that the almanac is predicting clear skies for Fourth of July fireworks, Duncan says.
    Chaussure Christian Louboutin

  27. But not as fancy when real world if you think mothers wrist are maybe not 2small don’t choose that reason things stay tight .. the adorable but anything yur 5year old can make . Non the particular reduced the one ok gifts and promote but not a wow present…cant go wrong in case dont have actually a lot to spend for a gift then get that

  28. But not like fancy inside real world if mothers wrist was not 2small don’t invest things result it make tight .. it is adorable and yet things yur 5year older can make . No the actual much less its a ok present in order to render but not the wow present…cant get wrong provided do not enjoy a great deal to blow for a gifts then get it

  29. I have the as being a gifts of our sister, happy mama. She loved things!! I became worried this had been will be too tiny due to the previous reviews and just how that seemed once I got per peak, however it in shape most well. It appearance gorgeous upon plus that beautiful bundle it’s presented as part of.

  30. I have your gifts to my personal mom of Holiday considering she are any precious jewelry freak. All one thing she cannot don a great deal regarding is actually, bracelets. I purchased this girl this appeal bracelet furthermore anytime she started that yesterday she absolutley loved things! This time the problem is, her getting it at to off simply by by herself. Haha… overall very good supplement, information technology delivered to came incredibly very early additionally my mom is enjoying that. Thank you.

Speak Your Mind